Renewables co-op fights Vattenfall for control of Berlin grid

A Berlin citizens’ group wants to wrest control of the city’s electricity grid in order to promote renewable energy. They accuse current operator Vattenfall of failing to seek alternatives to fossil fuels. Louise Osborne met the activists.

A citizens' initiative is questioning the power providers position in Germany.

Two citizens’ initiatives are questioning Vattenfall’s grid control in Berlin. (© Michael Paul/paulbewegt.de)


Two young women stand together behind a lectern at the front of a crowded room in Berlin. Their audience includes energy experts, activists and curious residents who are here to find out about a new initiative to buy Germany’s largest electricity distribution grid.

The grid is currently under the control of Swedish energy giant Vattenfall. But the people in this room say the utility has failed to embrace Germany’s transition to renewable energy and they want to take over grid control. The contract between the grid operator and Berlin’s government runs out at the end of 2014 and the two women speaking today – Luise Neumann-Cosel and Arwen Colell – have come up with a plan.

“It was May 2011, when Luise called me up on the phone saying the concession’s ending and we should buy the grid,” Colell told DW in an interview. “I thought, yeah, we really should.”

Recently, even the Federal Environment Minister Peter Altmaier became a member of the energy co-op BuergerEnergie Berlin. (Photo by BMU/Sascha Hilgers)

Recently, even Federal Environment Minister Peter Altmaier became a member of the energy co-op. (Photo by BMU/Sascha Hilgers)

The pair have formed BuergerEnergie Berlin (Citizen Energy Berlin), a cooperative which is pooling investments from members in order to make a bid for grid control. Colell and Neumann-Cosel have criss-crossed the country, building their concept with input from organizations like the Elektrizitaetswerke Schoenau (Electricity Utility Schoenau), a citizens’ group that operates the power grid in the German town of Schoenau.

“We had lots of worries,” said Colell. “We found out pretty quickly that there was no one who had done anything quite like this before – because of the sheer size of it.”

Renewables in the mix

BuergerEnergie Berlin now has more than 1,000 members and has attracted 5 million euros ($6.5 million) in investment. But they will need a lot more than this. The grid is valued closer to 800 million euros (about $1 billion).

“The role of the distribution grid is changing with renewable energies,” said Colell. “It used to be the last mile between the large coal or gas fired-generation power plants and the consumer. The task was pretty straight forward: get the energy to the people.”

Colell explained that decentralized generation of renewable energy through photovoltaic installations or turbines has made grid management more complicated. She doesn’t think Vattenfall has done enough to integrate renewables into the energy mix. Right now, less than three percent of Berlin’s energy is coming from renewable sources. That is far too low if Germany is going to wean itself off nuclear energy and fossil fuels.

But can these two young women pry control from high-level energy executives currently running the grid? They aren’t only competing with Vattenfall, but at least six other applicants.

Competition for grid control

The Berlin Senate will choose the next grid operator after assessing each applicant’s profile, including their financial resources and experience with energy management. The group that wins will run the grid for 20 years, from 2015 to 2035.

There is another citizens’ group that has taken interest in grid control. The Berliner Energietisch (Berlin Energy Table) wants the city to buy back grid control. Berlin’s electricity grid was run by the state-owned company Berliner Staedtische Elektrizitaetswerke, or BEWAG, until about a decade ago when Vattenfall took over. The Berlin Energy Table needs to gather 200,000 signatures by June 10 in order to request a referendum on public grid ownership.

The group’s spokesman Stefan Taschner says public ownership would bring the city closer to Germany’s climate protection goals. “Energy production has a large impact on CO2 emissions, so if we have this transition to renewable energy, we also make a contribution to climate protection,” he said.

“Vattenfall is still relying on coal energy production, like we see here in Brandenburg, not far from Berlin. They also rely on nuclear power plants,” said Taschner. “I don’t think a company that relies on that energy production has an interest in decentralized renewable energy here in Berlin.”

Competitive edge

Vattenfall has announced plans to increase the percentage of renewable energy in the Berlin grid. The energy giant is already converting a former district heating plant in Berlin into a biomass combined heat and power plant.

“Vattenfall and the former company BEWAG, [has] run the Berlin grid for more than 120 years, so we have the competence,” said company spokesman Hannes-Stefan Hoenemann. “We have the employees and all the know-how. In the concessions tendering process that will be very important,” he added.

But Vattenfall remains heavily invested in highly-polluting brown coal, which means they have an interest in pumping energy produced from fossil fuels into Berlin’s grid. The competition for grid control may provide new incentive for big utilities to commit more funds to renewables, even if local groups don’t gain control when Vattenfall’s concession ends next year.

Louise Osborne is a freelance journalist currently working in Berlin. Her article first appeared on and is kindly republished with permission by Deutsche Welle.

by

Energiewende Team

The "Energiewende Team" has an administrative function. We use this account to repost all the best articles about the global Energiewende from around the web.

1 Comment

  1. CaptD says

    Ratepayers want low cost, SAFE energy and Solar is now ready to provide it.

    There are only three things standing in the way of FIXING our global energy problem:

    1. Our powerful Utilities, want to keep us in Energy Slavery, so that we will be forced to purchase our energy from them instead of producing it ourselves for FREE (after the initial payback).

    2. Our appointed regulators, who have a too cozy relationship with the very Utilities they regulate! They have been putting Utility shareholder profits ahead of following their sworn mandate and demanding that our “public” utilities provide energy to US at the lowest cost possible! Example: Why should Utilities be allowed to rip off residential solar panel owners by not reimburse them for the energy they add to the grid at the very same rate that the Utility pays itself when it adds energy to the grid? This would “level” the energy playing field and greatly reduce the payback periods of owning your own panels, which would make installing solar even a better deal!

    3. Our Political Leaders are beholden to the Powerful Utilities because of large Utility donations and have been until recently hesitant to propose changes to “how the energy game is played” but now with a shrinking economy, the public resistance to ever higher energy costs and record Utility shareholder profits, energy is becoming a HOT political issue that Political Leaders cannot ignore any longer, if they want to stay in office or get elected.

Leave a Reply