2012 German Nuclear and Gas-Fired Generation Falls Further While Renewables Grow

A proper analysis of the composition of German electricity and the effects of renewables is often difficult to conduct as contradictory interpretations clash. Guest Author Paul Gipe from Wind-Works.org takes a step back and looks at the most recent data from a long-term perspective to shed some light on the developments caused by the energiewende.

Power Outlet

The electricity mix in Germany is getting greener. (Photo by Daniele Civello, CC BY-NC 2.0)


Apparently my article last October documenting the growth of renewables in Germany while nuclear generation continues to decline got under the skin of pro-nuclear bloggers.

So at the request of a reader, I am updating my charts on the electricity mix in Germany from 1990 through 2012. These charts are from public information, easily accessible with rudimentary German.

First, the total mix.
Total Power Mix 2012

As can be seen, renewables continue their steady increase. No surprises there. Hard coal arrests its decline and there’s a slight uptick in brown coal generation.


German Electricity Generation 1990-2012

Total generation of electricity in Germany remains relatively constant at 617 TWh in 2012.


German Coal-Fired Electricity Generation 1990-2012

In 2012 there was a slight uptick in coal-fired generation, mostly from brown coal. Generation from hard coal increased from 112 TWh to 118 TWh, about as much as the 117 TWh produced in 2010. Generation from brown coal increased from 150 TWh in 2011 to 158 TWh in 2012. Total coal-fired generation has increase about 25 TWh from a low of 254 TWh at the height of the Great Recession in 2009.


German Gas-Fired Electricity Generation 1990-2012

Despite a steady increase in gas-fired generation from the early 1990s through 2008, generation dropped dramatically in 2012 following a more gradual decline in 2011. Critics of the nuclear phase-out have charged that Germany is simply replacing nuclear with gas-fired generation. Apparently that’s not the case. Despite a slight increase in total generation in 2012, gas-fired generation dropped from 83 TWh in 2011 to 70 TWh. Gas-fired generation in Germany is now at the level last recorded in 2005 during the boom years prior to the Great Recession.


Germany Net Electricity Exports 1990-2012

Now on to the oft-repeated but never substantiated charge that Germany may be phasing out its nuclear plants but it is just turning around and importing nuclear-generated electricity from France. There was concern that German electricity exports would continue their fall from 2011, but that appears unwarranted. German exports of electricity surged in 2012. Net exports reached 23 TWh in 2012 for nearly 4% of total generation.


German Nuclear Electricity Generation 1990-2012

German nuclear generation continues to fall. For the first time in at least two decades nuclear generation fell below 100 TWh. Nuclear generation is now well below generation by new renewables (wind, solar, and biomass).


German Total Renewable Electricity Generation 1990-2012

Total renewable generation grew steadily to about 135 TWh, 35 TWh more than that from nuclear generation. Total renewable generation includes existing hydro about 20 TWh per year depending upon rainfall.


German New Renewable Generation 1990-2012

New renewable generation continued its remarkable growth in Germany in 2012, reaching nearly 115 TWh. Most growth has taken place since the country introduced a modern system of feed-in tariffs in the year 2000. New renewables now compares with the generation from hard coal and exceeds that from natural gas, nuclear, oil, and existing hydro.


German Renewable Electricity Generation 1990-2011

Solar photovoltaics (solar PV) continued its meteoric growth in 2012. Solar PV generated 29 TWh in 2012 or nearly 5% of total generation. Wind accounted for a little more than 7% of generation and biomass provided nearly 6% of generation.


German Renewable Generation 1990-2012

Renewable generation provided nearly 22% of total generation in 2012. Within a few years, renewables will account for one-fourth of all German electricity generation. New renewables accounted for nearly 19% of total German generation in 2012.

These comparisons are based on total generation and may not compare to other reports comparing the contribution of renewables to electricity consumption, 594 TWh.

Paul Gipe is a renewable energy industry analyst that has published several books on the topic. He first published this article on his website, wind-works.org.

1 Comment

  1. Phil says

    Hi Paul,

    Thanks for this data – very interesting and encouraging.

    You say that the claims that Germany is importing energy from France etc. are unsubstantiated but have also not listed a graph showing German energy imports. Is no such data available?

    I ask merely because I’d love to be able to categorically point to evidence as my partner’s father uses this argument all the time. Merely exporting more energy is not the best evidence that they are not importing as there is a certain uncontrollable element to renewable generation that means there quite often could be an over or under supply – meaning you would export more but also, potentially, import more.

    Hope you can point me in the right direction. Thanks again.

Leave a Reply